So here's the update for MY set of rebates (items purchased in this post). I was cleared for:
$10 RA Gift Card - SCR #18
$10 John Frieda/Biore SCR #41
$1 Crest SCR #39
These were all I expected, but I also qualified for SCR #13 - $5 for Metamucil! The sizes of the bottles I bought didn't match the ones listed in the SCR booklet, so I wasn't expecting this at all. Since I bought three different kinds of Metamucil this day (huge bottle, medium bottle and capsules), unfortunately I don't know which one did the trick.